George Harrar
George Harrar is a fiction writer whose short stories have appeared in a dozen literary magazines, including the 1999 edition of Best American Short Stories for “The 5:22”. His novels include The Spinning Man, a philosophical mystery (Putnam, February 2003); Not As Crazy As I Seem (Houghton Mifflin, April 2003); The Trouble with Jeremy Chance (Milkweed Editions, 2003); Parents Wanted (Milkweed Editions, 2001); and First Tiger (The Permanent Press, 1999). He is represented by Esmond Harmsworth of Zachary Shuster Harmsworth, Boston. Harrar grew up in Jenkintown, Pennsylvania and graduated from New York University. He worked as a journalist for many years, writing and editing on several newpapers and magazines. He lives now in Wayland, Massachusetts, with his wife, Linda, a documentary filmmaker whose work has appeared on PBS, Discovery, and Turner channels (web site: www.georgeharrar.com)
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: I got a chance to read your short story, 5:22 from
The Best American Short Stories 1999. I liked the virtual imagery behind the woman with a scar on one ear. It seems to me that you are a modern magical realism
writer. There are some who believe that Magical realism is listening to the way
words call to each other, evoking responses in the reader.
George Harrar: I think of myself as a story-teller, not a writer of any particular type.
“The 5:22” originally won the Carson Mc Cullers Prize for Short Stories from
Story magazine, and then was selected for Best American Short Stories of
1999 by the writer Amy Tan. Subsequently, I was approached by the editor of a
magical realism web site called Margin about their running the story online.
It was only then that I thought about magical realism at all. Many readers
have said that my story reminded them of “The Twilight Zone,” which was a
very well-written television series of the 1950s and 60s in which strange,
eerie events happened to the characters. What set this show apart is that
the strange events were not meant just to frighten or surprise the viewer,
they were meant to show something important about human relationships. My
story definitely has the feel of something strange going on-the woman with
a missing ear, the usual conductor gone, the train not making its
regular stop. My intent was to show how a single, random event-the wind
blowing the scarf off the woman’s head-can lead to a breakdown in
perception of reality. My main character finds the strength to hold on
during this chaotic period, and finally he regains control of his life when
he meets the woman again in the train. So, my story starts out “real” and
ends up “real” but in the middle is a bit of magical realism. I put “real”
in quotation marks because it is a little strange to refer to fictional
events as “real.”
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: What do you think about writing Magical realism?, -ism, literature stream, or postmodernism (most Vietnamese writers and critics discuss and focus on
postmodernism now. They strongly believe in its adoption.)
George Harrar: “The 5:22” is one of a few of my stories that might be considered magical realism. Perhaps one or two others might be considered postmodern, in the
sense that I break from the traditional story-telling form of beginning,
middle and end, with a progression of a character through conflict to
resolution. Philosophically, I suppose I see the world as being chaotic, and
increasingly so. Post-modern literature attempts to reflect this world in a
literary form that is itself often chaotic, or at least, disjointed. Traditional story-telling, as I generally practice it, may be less reflective of the modern (or post-modern) world, but I think it can be just as appealing to contemporary readers and perhaps even more insightful into human relationships than post-modern literature. Also, I believe the human
psyche craves the familiar, comforting rhythms of traditional story-telling.
.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Do you think that the history of world literature (in 20th century) is
influenced mainly by Western literature? Some believe that this is the case
because prominent writers have always heavily influenced history. Do you
agree? A future world without Western influences would result in the fall
of American literature. In your opinion, what would this world be like?
George Harrar: It is difficult to separate out the influence of Western literature on other
cultures from the influence of other Western attributes, such as movies,
music and commercial products. I believe we may be living in a time when
writers of any culture are having less influence, because of the dominance
of television, the internet, and other media. I’m sure the world could survive quite well without current American literature. I would hope, though, that some of the classic American books from Twain, Poe, Faulkner, Hemingway, Fitzgerald and Wolfe (Thomas, not Tom) might endure.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Many writers in the world read and learn American literature, but most American writers do not focus on foreign literature. What is your opinion
on this matter?
George Harrar: As I scan my bookshelves, I see novels from Ireland (Angela’s Ashes),
Nigeria (The Famished Road), Japan (One Hundred and One Ways), India (The
Snake Charmer), Columbia (Love in the Time of Cholera), Italy (The Name of
the Rose), South Africa (Disgrace), and England (Enduring Love) to name a
few. I believe my bookshelf is typical not just of many American writers, but of
many American readers. Unfortunately, most Americans in general don’t read
novels. My brother, for example, has read only one book in his life-my
novel, titled The Spinning Man. Also, understand that America is so large that many people here don’t feel the need to look across the oceans to other countries for literature or other ideas. Since educated people all across the world know English, many here feel it is unnecessary to learn a second language. I disagree. I believe it is worthwhile to learn at least one foreign language, and mine is Spanish. I read and write in Spanish quite well, and I take every opportunity to speak in Spanish with the many immigrants from
Central and South America now living here. My wife is studying Spanish now
and can also speak French well enough for us to travel in French-speaking
countries.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: What is your opinion on the value of American literature about
Vietnamese topics
George Harrar: The only novels that I am aware of about Vietnam from an American
perspective relate to the war there in the 1960s and 70s. These novels don’t
relate what life is like in Vietnam now, I’m sure.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Have you ever read a novel written by a Vietnamese author?
George Harrar: No, but I would be happy to if you could suggest a novel that has been
translated into English.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Vietnam previously had a close-door policy aimed at restricting any foreign influences. Past Vietnamese literature was heavily influenced by
politics and policy. Now the situation has changed. While reaching to the
outside, Vietnamese writers have become overwhelmed by outside influences
and confused on which influences to consider. If you were a Vietnamese
writer, what would your reactions be? Vietnamese writers usually interact
with only about 5% of the world’s opinions. As an American writer, you are
in constant interaction with multiple views and foreign influences. How do
you respond in these situations?
George Harrar: Any writer must decide whether to write from his or her own heart, soul and mind, or whether to be more outer-directed, considering markets and outside
influences. It feels presumptuous of me to suggest anything to a writer in
Vietnam. I would only say that the truest literature seems to come from
writers who focus on their own experiences rather than on what someone else
expects of him or her. Two of the most prestigious American magazines, The
New Yorker and Atlantic Monthly, regularly run stories by writers living in
India and China. I have not read a story there by a Vietnamese writer, but I
would think those magazines would welcome a submission from your country,
particularly where the writer expresses the unique Vietnamese perspective on
life there now. As for influences on my writing, I don’t see myself as part of any genre or
school of writing. I write what I feel, which comes from my lifelong
experiences and outlook on life. I’m sure what I read in newspapers and hear
on television and radio from foreign countries work its way into my
subconscious, and then into my writing. I don’t make any special effort to
open myself up to these influences or to avoid them. I take in all of life
that is around me, however it appears to me, and that forms the basis of
what I write.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Due to the increase in popular music and entertainment media, American literature is no longer part of mainstream artistic and intellectual life.
It has become categorized as subculture. Reading has declined and Americans
have lost their interests in literature. What are you opinions on this
matter?
George Harrar: Americans do read a great deal, but much of it is non-fiction, in
newspapers, magazines and books. In terms of fiction, great numbers of
Americans read so-called “popular” authors, such as Tom Clancy, John Grisham
and Stephen King. Their books are not considered particularly well-written,
but they do offer exciting, fast-moving plots that appeal to people. My own
stories and novels are more subtle, more literary. A few literary novels
“break out,” meaning that they become widely sold because of a combination
of good marketing and a good story. Most literary novels, though, develop
only a relatively small following-perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 hardbacks sold.
The key to developing a reading American public as adults is to reach them
with good stories as children. I also write for younger readers and have
published three novels for ages nine and up. My hope is to excite them about
reading and about the world at an early age.
Trịnh Thanh Thủy: Do you have any final thoughts or anything to share with our
Vietnamese readers?
George Harrar: If you are writers, write-and stay faithful to your inner voice as to how you want to express yourself. If you are readers, read-and hold writers to the highest standards.
© 2003 talawas